Navigating Spiritual Dissonance: When Jesus Challenges What We Think We Know

 


Have you ever experienced dissonance?


In music, dissonance refers to a clash of notes—a sound that feels unresolved or uncomfortable. In daily life, we encounter simple forms of dissonance all the time:

  • The morning alarm: Is that a pleasant sound when it interrupts your sleep?

  • A crying baby: Is that a noise any of us truly enjoy?

  • Healthy eating: You decide to eat clean, yet that slice of cake, homemade ice cream, or cupcake entices you. Do you feel guilty afterward for eating what you previously decided wasn't right for your goals?

In psychology, this friction is called cognitive dissonance—the psychological conflict that results from holding incongruous beliefs and attitudes simultaneously, or experiencing an inconsistency between your actions and your core beliefs.

What Triggers Cognitive Dissonance?

Spiritual and mental friction often arises from a few common experiences:

  1. Receiving New Information: When truth confronts old habits, friction is inevitable.

  2. Experiencing Social Pressure: We want to fit in, but external expectations collide with our conviction. In severe cases of social pressure, it feels like we aren't allowed to make a different choice without risking exclusion from the group.

    • Scriptural Example: Consider the parents of the blind man Jesus healed in John 9:22: "His parents said this because they were afraid of the Jews, for already the Jews had decided that anyone who acknowledged that Jesus was the Christ would be put out of the synagogue."

  3. Needing to Make a Choice: With endless perspectives available today, we easily fall into decision paralysis or polythink—a dynamic where conflicting opinions within a group (or even within our own minds) prevent decisive action.

The Disciples and Spiritual Dissonance

Throughout the Gospel accounts, Matthew shows us that the disciples frequently lived in a state of spiritual cognitive dissonance.

For years, religious leaders taught them specific expectations about God and the coming Messiah—that He would be a political deliverer who would restore Israel, free them from earthly bondage, and elevate their nation.

Then Jesus arrived, and His teaching completely turned those expectations upside down:

  • Confronting Tradition: Jesus continually challenged the rigid traditions of religious leaders.

  • Redefining Purity: Jesus showed them that it is not what enters the mouth that makes a person unclean, but what comes out of the heart. In doing so, He declared all foods clean—directly contradicting their upbringing.

  • Inclusion of All People: Jesus demonstrated that no group of people is beyond God's reach. Access to the Father was no longer restricted by cultural inheritance, but opened to anyone who chooses to believe.

  • The Suffering Messiah: Right after Peter declared Jesus to be "the Christ, the Son of the living God," Jesus revealed that He must go to Jerusalem, suffer, be killed, and rise on the third day. A suffering savior did not fit their framework.

  • True Greatness: Even after witnessing the Transfiguration, the disciples argued about who would be the greatest in the Kingdom. Jesus placed a child in their midst, teaching that true greatness requires childlike faith, humility, and a servant’s heart.

Resolving Conflict in the Family of God

In Matthew 18, Jesus addresses another area that often creates tension: how to handle offense and sin within the body of believers.

"If your brother sins against you, go and show him his fault, just between the two of you. If he listens to you, you have won your brother over."

— Matthew 18:15

When someone in the church family sins or offends us, Jesus provides a clear, three-step framework for reconciliation:

Step 1: Private Conversation

Go directly to the person privately to speak the truth in love—not to win an argument or condemn, but to restore the relationship. Often, offenses stem from misunderstandings or unexamined behavior.

Step 2: Small Group Witness

If private reconciliation fails, take one or two mature believers along (Matthew 18:16). This keeps the focus on truth and accountability rather than personal bias.

Step 3: Church Accountability

If the individual refuses to listen to the small group, bring the matter before the wider church body (Matthew 18:17).

In modern culture, holding one another accountable feels uncomfortable because defining right and wrong often conflicts with worldly norms. Yet scripture reminds us that genuine love prioritizes spiritual health over temporary comfort.

The Promise of His Presence

Following these challenging instructions, Jesus offers comfort:

"For where two or three come together in my name, there am I with them."

— Matthew 18:20

Whether in a formal gathering or daily life, believers are the temple of the Holy Spirit. His presence goes with us into every conversation, meeting, and quiet moment of reflection.

How to Process Spiritual Dissonance

The next time you experience internal tension between culture, personal desires, and Scripture, ask yourself these four questions:

  1. What are the two competing beliefs or ideas that don't fit together?

  2. What practical actions are required to resolve this tension?

  3. Do I need to change a specific behavior, or is God calling me to transform my mindset?

  4. How important is it for me to align my heart with God's truth today?

Ultimately, processing spiritual dissonance brings us back to one central question Jesus asked His disciples:

"Who do you say that I am?"

Originally delivered 2023.9.10

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Beyond the Misquote: What Jesus Really Said About Judging Others

Overcoming the World: Choosing the Inheritance of God

Moving Beyond Outward Appearance to a Heart for God